BAILII is celebrating 24 years of free online access to the law! Would you consider making a contribution?

    No donation is too small. If every visitor before 31 December gives just £1, it will have a significant impact on BAILII's ability to continue providing free access to the law.
    Thank you very much for your support!



    BAILII [Home] [Databases] [World Law] [Multidatabase Search] [Help] [Feedback]

    European Court of Human Rights
    You are here: BAILII >> Databases >> European Court of Human Rights >> Stanislav Petrovich ALYOKHIN v Ukraine - 26316/09 [2012] ECHR 398 (21 February 2012)
    URL: http://www.bailii.org/eu/cases/ECHR/2012/398.html
    Cite as: [2012] ECHR 398

    [New search] [Contents list] [Printable RTF version] [Help]


    FIFTH SECTION

    DECISION

    Application no. 26316/09
    Stanislav Petrovich ALYOKHIN against Ukraine
    and 138 other applications
    (see list appended)

    The European Court of Human Rights (Fifth Section), sitting on 21 February 2012 as a Committee composed of:

    Mark Villiger, President,
     Karel Jungwiert,
     André Potocki, judges,
    and Stephen Phillips, Deputy Section Registrar,

    Having regard to the above applications lodged on the dates specified in the annexed table,

    Having deliberated, decides as follows:

    THE FACTS

    The applicants are Ukrainian nationals whose names and dates of birth are specified in the annexed table. They were represented by Mr N. Pedan, a lawyer practising in Slovyansk. The Ukrainian Government (“the Government”) were represented by Ms V. Lutkovska, of the Ministry of Justice.

    The applicants are former employees of the State-owned plant “Sodovyy Zavod”. On the dates specified in the annexed table the Slovyansk Court and the labour dispute commission ordered the plant to pay the applicants various work-related sums. The decisions in the applicants’ favour became final but remain unenforced.

    COMPLAINTS

    Relying on Articles 4, 6 § 1 and 13 of the Convention and Article 1 of Protocol No. 1, the applicants complained about the lengthy non enforcement of the decisions given in their favour.

    THE LAW

  1. The Court considers that in accordance with Rule 42 § 1 of the Rules of Court, the applications should be joined, given their common factual and legal background.

  2. The Court notes that the applicants’ complaints about the non-enforcement fall to be examined under Article 6 § 1 of the Convention and Article 1 of Protocol No. 1, which read, insofar as relevant, as follows:

    3. Article 6

    “In the determination of his civil rights and obligations ... everyone is entitled to a fair ... hearing within a reasonable time by [a] ... tribunal ...”

    Article 1 of Protocol No. 1

    “Every natural or legal person is entitled to the peaceful enjoyment of his possessions. No one shall be deprived of his possessions except in the public interest and subject to the conditions provided for by law and by the general principles of international law.

    The preceding provisions shall not, however, in any way impair the right of a State to enforce such laws as it deems necessary to control the use of property in accordance with the general interest or to secure the payment of taxes or other contributions or penalties.”

  3. Referring to the Yuriy Nikolayevich Ivanov pilot judgment (no. 40450/04, ECHR 2009 ... (extracts)), on 19 July 2011 the Government submitted to the Court unilateral declarations aimed at resolving the issues raised in the applications. By these declarations, the Government acknowledged the excessive duration of the enforcement of the decisions in the applicants’ favour, declared that they were ready to pay the applicants the outstanding debts under the decisions and the sums specified in the annexed table. The Government invited the Court to strike the applications out of the list of cases pursuant to Article 37 § 1 (c) of the Convention.

    4. The declarations also provided that the compensation sums were to cover any pecuniary and non-pecuniary damage as well as costs and expenses, to be converted into the national currency of the respondent State at the rate applicable on the date of settlement. The sums would be payable within three months from the date of notification of the decision taken by the Court pursuant to Article 37 § 1 of the European Convention on Human Rights. In the event of failure to pay these sums within the said three-month period, the Government undertook to pay simple interest on them from expiry of that period until settlement, at a rate equal to the marginal lending rate of the European Central Bank during the default period plus three percentage points. The declarations provided that these payments would constitute the final resolution of the cases.

    The applicants either disagreed with the declarations on various grounds and requested the Court to pursue the examination of their cases or did not provide any comments.

    The Court reiterates that it may at any stage of the proceedings strike an application out of its list of cases where the circumstances lead to the conclusions specified under Article 37 § 1 (a)-(c) of the Convention. In particular, under Article 37 § 1 (c) the Court may strike a case out of its list if for any other reason established by the Court, it is no longer justified to continue the examination of the application.

    Article 37 § 1 in fine states:

    “However, the Court shall continue the examination of the application if respect for human rights as defined in the Convention and the protocols thereto so requires”.

    The Court also reiterates that in certain circumstances it may strike out an application under Article 37 § 1 (c) on the basis of a unilateral declaration made by a respondent Government even if the applicant wishes the examination of the case to be continued (see Tahsin Acar v. Turkey (preliminary issue) [GC], no. 26307/95, §§ 75-77, ECHR 2003-VI).

    The Court recalls that in its pilot judgment on the issues of the non-enforcement it ordered Ukraine to grant redress to the applicants whose applications were communicated to the Government before the delivery of the judgment or would be communicated further to the judgment and concerned complaints about the prolonged non-enforcement of domestic decisions for which the State was responsible (see Yuriy Nikolayevich Ivanov, cited above, § 99 and point 6 of the operative part). Having examined the terms of the Government’s declarations, the Court understands them as intending to give the applicants the redress in accordance with the pilot judgment.

    The Court is satisfied that the Government explicitly acknowledge the excessive duration of the enforcement of the decisions given in the applicants’ favour and undertake to enforce the decisions which have not been enforced yet. It also notes that the compensation sums offered by the Government are comparable with Court awards in similar cases, taking account, inter alia, of the specific delay in each particular case.

    The Court therefore considers that it is no longer justified to continue the examination of the applications. It is also satisfied that respect for human rights as defined in the Convention and the Protocols thereto does not require it to continue the examination of the applications. Accordingly, they should be struck out of the list.

    For these reasons, the Court unanimously

    Decides to join the applications;

    Takes note of the terms of the respondent Government’s declarations in respect of the applicants’ complaints about the delayed enforcement of the domestic decisions given in their favour;

    Decides to strike the applications out of its list of cases in accordance with Article 37 § 1 (c) of the Convention.

    Stephen Phillips Mark Villiger
    Deputy Registrar President

    APPENDIX


    No.

    Application
    n    umber

    Applicant’s name, born in

    Domestic decisions about the lengthy non-enforcement of which the applicants complain (date of the decision and name of the court

    or labour dispute commission (LDC), sum awarded

    Compensation offered

    by the Government

    (in euros)

    1

    26316/09

    ALYOKHIN

    STANISLAV PETROVICH, 1945

    1) Slovyansk Court, 03.10.1997

    2) LDC, 12.04.2002

    2,475

    2

    26317/09

    ALYOKHINA

    YELENA GRIGORYEVNA, 1947

    1) Slovyansk Court, 31.10.1997

    2) LDC, 10.02.2004

    2,460

    3

    26318/09

    ANDRIYEVSKAYA

    ALLA PAVLOVNA, 1947

    Slovyansk Court, 04.11.1997

    2,445

    4

    26319/09

    ARTEMENKO

    VIKTOR IVANOVICH, 1939

    LDC, 07.10.2002

    1,575

    5

    26320/09

    ARTEMENKO

    NEONILA ANATOLYEVNA, 1945

    LDC, 07.10.2002

    1,575

    6

    26321/09

    AKHTYRTSEVA

    VALENTINA BORISOVNA, 1948

    Slovyansk Court, 22.02.2001

    1,860

    7

    26322/09

    BERBENKO

    LYUDMILA ANDREYEVNA 1956

    Slovyansk Court, 20.10.1997

    2,460

    8

    26323/09

    BOZHENKO

    NIKOLAY IVANOVICH, 1950

    1) Slovyansk Court, 15.12.1997, 20.04.2000,

    2) LDC, 08.09.2003

    2,430

    9

    26324/09

    BUDULEVA

    OLGA NIKOLAYEVNA 1956

    1) Slovyansk Court, 26.04.1999

    2) LDC, 13.09.2001

    2,190

    10

    26325/09

    BULAVENKO

    ZINAIDA GRIGORYEVNA,1932

    Slovyansk Court, 25.11.1997, 16.12.1998

    2,445

    11

    26326/09

    BUKHTIYAROV

    ANATOLIY FEDOROVICH,1950

    1) Slovyansk Court, 02.02.1998

    2) LDC, 10.12.2002

    2,415

    12

    26327/09

    VAYNAGIY

    VALENTINA VASILYEVNA,1969

    Slovyansk Court, 29.03.1999, 10.11.2003

    2,205

    13

    26328/09

    VELIKAYA

    NADEZHDA TIMOFEYEVNA,1950

    LDC, 15.09.2003

    1,410

    14

    26331/09

    VOLOSHCHENKO

    VALENTYNA VASILYEVNA,1956

    LDC, 14.12.2001

    1,725

    15

    26332/09

    VOROBYOVA

    YEVGENIYA ALEKSEYEVNA,1947

    Slovyansk Court, 29.03.1999

    2,205

    16

    26333/09

    VOROBYOVA

    NINA ANDREYEVNA,1938

    Slovyansk Court, 06.11.1997

    2,445

    17

    26334/09

    VORONOVA

    VALENTINA NIKOLAYEVNA,1960

    Slovyansk Court, 06.10.1997

    2,460

    18

    26335/09

    VOROSHCHUK

    ANDREY SERGEYEVICH,1980

    LDC, 13.02.2003

    1,515

    19

    26336/09

    VOROSHCHUK

    SERGEY IVANOVICH,1955

    LDC, 13.02.2003

    1,515

    20

    26337/09

    GAYDELIS

    OLEG GENNADIYEVICH,1967

    1) Slovyansk Court, 24.11.1997

    2) LDC, 09.07.2003

    2,445

    21

    26338/09

    GLOTOV

    IVAN KONSTANTINOVICH,1947

    Slovyansk Court, 31.10.1997

    2,460

    22

    26339/09

    GLOTOVA

    LYUBOV VASILYEVNA,1948

    Slovyansk Court, 31.10.1997

    2,460

    23

    26340/09

    GONCHAROVA

    RAISA IVANOVNA,1951

    Slovyansk Court, 02.12.1997

    2,445

    24

    26341/09

    GORBASENKO

    VLADIMIR GR1GORYEVICH,1955

    Slovyansk Court, 14.10.1997, 13.02.1998, 24.05.1999,

    2,475

    25

    26342/09

    GREBENYUK NINA ABRAMOVNA, 1934

    LDC, 23.02.2004

    1,320

    26

    26343/09

    GRINYOV IVAN IVANOVICH, 1943

    Slovyansk Court, 27.01.1998

    2,415

    27

    26344/09

    GRINKOV

    GENNADIY VLADIMIROVICH, 1976

    1) Slovyansk Court, 03.10.1997

    2) LDC, 09.02.2004

    2,475

    28

    26345/09

    GRUNSKOY

    SERGEY ALEKSANDROVICH, 1956

    Slovyansk Court, 14.10.1997

    2,475

    29

    26346/09

    GUZIKOV VIKTOR IVANOVICH, 1940

    1) Slovyansk Court, 31.10.1997, 12.06.1998

    2) LDC, 19.02.2002

    2,460

    30

    26347/09

    GURINA LYUBOV VASILYEVNA, 1951

    1) Slovyansk Court 20.01.1998

    2) LDC, 20.03.2002

    2,415

    31

    26348/09

    DEMCHENKO NADEZHDA FEDOROVNA, 1957

    LDC, 31.01.2002, 19.01.2004

    1,695

    32

    26349/09

    DOLGIKH NATALYA NIKOLAYEVNA, 1954

    Slovyansk Court, 22.10.1997

    2,460

    33

    26350/09

    YEGORCHENKO

    ANATOLIY NIKOLAYEVICH, 1935

    LDC, 13.02.2003

    1,515

    34

    26351/09

    YEGORCHENKO

    VERA ALEKSANDROVNA, 1936

    LDC, 23.02.2004

    1,320

    35

    26352/09

    YERESHCHENKO

    YEKATERINA FEDOROVNA, 1928

    Slovyansk Court, 04.12.2000

    1,905

    36

    26354/09

    YEFIMOVA NINA NIKOLAYEVNA, 1926

    1) Slovyansk Court, 02.12.1997, 18.07.2002

    2) LDC, 09.02.2004

    2,445

    37

    26355/09

    ZHYLIN VASILIY YAKOVLEVICH, 1948

    Slovyansk Court, 12.06.1998, 03.09.1998

    2,355

    38

    26356/09

    ZAGREBELNYY

    DMITRIY YEVGENYEVICH, 1960

    1) Slovyansk Court, 17.11.1997

    2) LDC, 28.02.2002

    2,445

    39

    26357/09

    ZADOROZHNIY

    MIKHAIL ALEKSANDROVICH, 1960

    Slovyansk Court, 06.10.1997, 20.03.2000

    2,475

    40

    26358/09

    ZAYTSEV NIKOLAY VLADIMIROVICH, 1951

    Slovyansk Court, 24.11.1997

    2,445

    41

    26359/09

    ZUBRITSKJY ANATOLIY FEDOROVICH, 1936

    Slovyansk Court, 29.05.2000

    1,995

    42

    26360/09

    1VANOV ALEKSANDR YAKOVLEVICH, 1956

    Slovyansk Court, 26.01.1998

    2,415

    43

    26362/09

    IOSIPOVICH TATYANA MIKHAYLOVNA, 1971

    Slovyansk Court, 13.10.1997

    2,460

    44

    26363/09

    KABATSKAYA MARIYA MARKOVNA, 1937

    1) Slovyansk Court, 09.10.1997

    2) LDC, 13.10.2003

    2,460

    45

    26364/09

    KALIBERDA

    ALEKSANDR ANATOLYEVICH, 1975

    Slovyansk Court, 05.11.1997

    2,460

    46

    26365/09

    KATAYEV MIKHAIL IVANOVICH, 1946

    Slovyansk Court, 20.10.1997

    2,460

    47

    26366/09

    KATAYEVA ALLA KUZMINICHNA, 1950

    Slovyansk Court, 20.10.1997

    2,460

    48

    26368/09

    KIRKACH LYUBOV VASILYEVNA, 1956

    Slovyansk Court, 03.11.1997, 30.03.2001

    2,460

    49

    26369/09

    KOVALYOVA VALENTINA IVANOVNA, 1951

    Slovyansk Court, 15.02.1999

    2,235

    50

    26371/09

    KOZHENTSEV VIKTOR NIKIFOROVYCH, 1945

    LDC, 19.02.2002

    1,680

    51

    26372/09

    KOLESNIK IVAN NIKOLAYEVICH, 1951

    1) Slovyansk Court, 28.10.1997, 21.06.1999

    2) LDC 15.01.2001

    2,460

    52

    26373/09

    KOLESNIK LYUDMILA ANDREYEVNA, 1951

    1) Slovyansk Court, 03.10.1997, 21.06.1999

    2) LDC, 14.12.2001

    2,475

    53

    26374/09

    KOLESNIK NIKOLAY IVANOVICH, 1978

    Slovyansk Court, 24.05.1999

    2,175

    54

    26375/09

    KOLMYKOV ALEKSANDR IVANOVICH, 1972

    Slovyansk Court, 29.03.1999

    2,205

    55

    26376/09

    KOLMYKOVA MARIYA FROLOVNA, 1942

    Slovyansk Court, 17.02.1998

    2,400

    56

    26378/09

    KONYUKHOV VITALIY FEDOROVICH, 1944

    Slovyansk Court, 08.10.1997

    2,475

    57

    26379/09

    KOSTRUB

    VLADIMIR ALEKSANDROVICH, 1950

    1) Slovyansk Court, 20.10.1997

    2) LDC, 08.09.2003

    2,460

    58

    26380/09

    KOSTRUB LYUBOV VASILYEVNA, 1952

    1) Slovyansk Court, 20.10.1997, 04.12.1998

    2) LDC, 08.09.2003

    2,460

    59

    26381/09

    KOTLYAROVA

    TAMARA ANATOLYEVNA, 1946

    Slovyansk Court, 24.10.1997, 26.06.1998, 07.06.1999

    2,460

    60

    26382/09

    KRAVTSOVA IRINA LEONIDOVNA, 1954

    Slovyansk Court, 06.10.1997

    2,460

    61

    26383/09

    KRAVCHENKO VADIM VALENTINOVICH, 1971

    Slovyansk Court,01.12.1997

    2,445

    62

    26384/09

    KUZNETSOVA

    YELENA ALEKSANDROVNA, 1952

    Slovyansk Court, 23.12.1998

    2,250

    63

    26385/09

    KRAVCHENKO LYUBOV IVANOVNA, 1939

    Slovyansk Court, 06.10.1997

    2,475

    64

    26386/09

    KUPRIYANOV

    ANATOLIY ALEKSEYEVICH, 1940

    Slovyansk Court, 25.08.1998

    2,310

    65

    26387/09

    KUKHARENKO IGOR ALEKSEYEVICH, 1960

    Slovyansk Court, 24.10.1997

    2,460

    66

    26388/09

    KUKHARENKO YULIYA NIKOLAYEVNA, 1956

    Slovyansk Court, 24.10.1997, 17.11.2003

    2,460

    67

    26389/09

    KUSHELEV VLADIMIR VASILYEVICH, 1941

    Slovyansk Court, 24.10.1997

    2,460

    68

    26390/09

    KUSHNIR ANNA IVANOVNA, 1938

    LDC, 23.02.2004

    1,320

    69

    26392/09

    LARIONOV OLEG NIKOLAYEVICH, 1925

    Slovyansk Court, 15.10.1997, 24.06.1999

    2,460

    70

    26393/09

    LYAGUZIN VADIM MIKHAYLOVICH, 1945

    1) Slovyansk Court, 13.02.1998, 05.04.1999

    2) LDC, 15.09.2003

    2,415

    71

    26394/09

    LYASHENKO NIKOLAY VASILYEVICH, 1936

    Slovyansk Court, 05.11.1997, 20.09.2000

    2,460

    72

    26395/09

    MARKIN YEVGENIY DMITRIYEVICH, 1962

    Slovyansk Court, 05.04.1999

    2,205

    73

    26396/09

    MARKINA

    ALEKSANDRA ALEKSEYEVNA, 1932

    Slovyansk Court, 19.04.1999

    2,190

    74

    26398/09

    MISANYETS YELENA VLADIMIROVNA, 1968

    1) Slovyansk Court, 22.12.1998

    2) LDC, l9.03.2002

    2,250

    75

    26400/09

    MOROZOV VLADIMIR VENIAMINOVICH, 1958

    Slovyansk Court, 14.10.1997, 13.09.1999

    2,460

    76

    26401/09

    MOSKVIN VLADIMIR VASILYEVICH, 1948

    1) Slovyansk Court, 28.04.2000

    2) LDC, 13.09.2001

    2,010

    77

    26402/09

    MOSKVINA LYUDMILA ILYINICHNA, 1955

    1) Slovyansk Court28.04.2000

    2) LDC, 13.09.2001

    2,010

    78

    26403/09

    NAZARENKO IVAN IGNATYEVICH, 1926

    Slovyansk Court, 13.10.1997, 19.03.2001

    2,475

    79

    26404/09

    NEBRATENKO VLADIMIR OLEGOVICH, 1961

    1) Slovyansk Court, 20.03.2000

    2) LDC, 24.09.2002

    2,025

    80

    26405/09

    NEBRATENKO OLGA NIKOLAYEVNA, 1956

    1) Slovyansk Court, 20.03.2000

    2) LDC, 24.09.2002

    2,025

    81

    26406/09

    NEVMIRICH IVAN MIKHAYLOVICH, 1936

    Slovyansk Court, 20.01.1998

    2,415

    82

    26407/09

    NEMINUSHCHAYA

    YELENA MIKHAYLOVNA, 1968

    Slovyansk Court, 13.10.1997

    2,475

    83

    26408/09

    NECHITAYLO OLGA ALEKSEYEVNA, 1953

    Slovyansk Court, 05.04.1999

    2,190

    84

    26409/09

    NOTCHENKO LYUDMILA IVANOVNA, 1953

    Slovyansk Court, 14.05.1998, 21.12.2000

    2,355

    85

    26410/09

    ODINENKO VADIM YEMELYANOVICH, 1936

    Slovyansk Court, 27.03.2000, 05.10.2004

    2,025

    86

    26411/09

    OLEYNIK VYACHESLAV LEONIDOVICH, 1957

    Slovyansk Court, 13.10.1997, 20.01.1998

    2,460

    87

    26413/09

    PAVLENKO RAISA TIMOFEYEVNA, 1939

    LDC, 10.02.2004

    1,335

    88

    26414/09

    PLATONOV ALEKSANDR VLASOVICH, 1938

    Slovyansk Court, 24.10.1997, 27.03.2000,

    2,460

    89

    26415/09

    PLATONOV

    ARKADIY ALEKSANDROVICH, 1963

    Slovyansk Court 05.11.1997, 27.03.2000

    2,460

    90

    26416/09

    PLUZHNIK LARISA VALENTINOVNA, 1959

    LDC, 13.09.2001

    1,770

    91

    26417/09

    PODKOVALNIKOVA LYUMILA VLADIMIROVNA, 1950

    Slovyansk Court, 24.12.1997

    2,430

    92

    26418/09

    PODNOGINA VERA IVANOVNA, 1948

    LDC, 19.02.2002

    1,680

    93

    26420/09

    PRIYMENKO LYUBOV VASILYEVNA, 1961

    1) Slovyansk Court, 05.11.1997

    2) LDC, 06.03.2001, 18.08.2003

    2,460

    94

    26421/09

    PRISTINSKAYA INNA ANATOLYEVNA, 1971

    Slovyansk Court 19.04.1999

    2,190

    95

    26422/09

    PRIYMENKO ALEKSANDR ANTONOVICH, 1961

    1) Slovyansk Court, 05.11.1997

    2) LDC, 06.03.200118.08.2003,

    2,460

    96

    26423/09

    RABOCHIY NIKOLAY FEDOROVICH, 1952

    1) Slovyansk Court, 29.05.2000

    2) LDC, 13.09.2001

    1, 995

    97

    26424/09

    RASSKAZOVA

    TATYANA ALEKSANDROVNA, 1954

    LDC, 20.03.2002

    1,665

    98

    26425/09

    REVA SERGEY VLADIMIROVICH, 1929

    Slovyansk Court, 02.12.1997

    2,430

    99

    26426/09

    ROY NATALYA NIKOLAYEVNA, 1977

    Slovyansk Court, 16.08.1999

    2,130

    100

    26427/09

    ROSININA SVETLANA ANATOLYEVNA, 1940

    Slovyansk Court, 27.10.1997

    2,460

    101

    26428/09

    RUBTSOV VLADIMIR ILYICH, 1935

    Slovyansk Court, 03.11.1997, 12.06.1998

    2,445

    102

    26429/09

    RUTYNA ROZA NIKOLAYEVNA, 1952

    1) Slovyansk Court, 03.09.1997, 07.06.1999

    2) LDC, 12.11.2002

    2,490

    103

    26430/09

    RUDENKO ANTONINA AFANASYEVNA, 1951

    Slovyansk Court, 24.10.1997

    2,460

    104

    26431/09

    RUDENKO VIKTOR ALEKSEYVICH, 1947

    Slovyansk Court, 03.11.1997

    2,460

    105

    26432/09

    SAVCHENKO

    YEFROSINIYA ALESKANDROVNA, 1952

    1) Slovyansk Court, 05.11.1997

    2) LDC, 17.01.2002

    2,460

    106

    26435/09

    SEDASHEV LEONID VLADIMIROVICH, 1961

    Slovyansk Court, 27.10.1997, 16.08.2000

    2,460

    107

    26436/09

    SEMENENKO

    VLADIMIR SPIRIDONOVICH, 1944

    Slovyansk Court, 31.10.1997

    2,460

    108

    26437/09

    SEREDA ALEKSANDR IVANOVICH, 1949

    Slovyansk Court, 30.10.1997

    2,460

    109

    26438/09

    SEMENIKHINA

    YELENA ALEKSANDROVNA, 1966

    Slovyansk Court 24.07.2000, 17.08.1998

    2,310

    110

    26439/09

    SLEPTSOV NIKOLAY IVANOVICH, 1954

    Slovyansk Court 03.12.1998

    2,265

    111

    26440/09

    SLEPTSOVA RAISA MIKHAYLOVNA, 1954

    Slovyansk Court 18.08.2000, 28.09.2001

    1,950

    112

    26449/09

    STRELIN NIKOLAY NIKOLAYEVICH, 1949

    1) Slovyansk Court, 26.04.1999

    2) LDC, 13.09.2001

    2,190

    113

    26450/09

    STRELINA NINA FEDOROVNA, 1956

    1) Slovyansk Court 26.09.2001

    2) LDC, 13.09.2001

    1,740

    114

    26451/09

    TANABASH VASILIY ALEKSEYEVICH, 1931

    Slovyansk Court,03.10.1997, 28.01.1998, 28.09.2001,

    2,475

    115

    26452/09

    TARAN ANATOLIY ALEKSANDROVICH, 1951

    Slovyansk Court, 11.11.1997

    2,460

    116

    26453/09

    TARAN VERA ANDREYEVNA, 1952

    Slovyansk Court, 11.11.1997

    2,460

    117

    26454/09

    TARASYUK NADEZHDA MIKHAYLOVNA, 1959

    Slovyansk Court, 26.01.1998

    2,415

    118

    26455/09

    TERESHENKO ALEKSANDR PETROVICH, 1959

    Slovyansk Court, 02.10.1997

    2,475

    119

    26456/09

    TERESHENKO OLGA IVANOVNA, 1960

    Slovyansk Court, 27.10.1997

    2,460

    120

    26457/09

    TERESHENKO PETR ANDREYEVICH, 1932

    Slovyansk Court, 27.11.1998

    2,265

    121

    26458/09

    TIKHOMIROVA OLGA FEDOROVNA, 1953

    Slovyansk Court, 06.10.1997, 20.12.1999

    2,460

    122

    26460/09

    TOVMA VALENTINA PETROVNA, 1944

    Slovyansk Court, 03.11.1997, 29.03.1999, 16.12.2002

    2,445

    123

    26461/09

    TONKOSHKUR ZOYA AFANASIEVNA, 1937

    Slovyansk Court, 10.10.2000

    1,935

    124

    26462/09

    TREFILOVA

    NADEZHDA GENNADYEVNA, 1953

    Slovyansk Court, 11.05.1999

    2,190

    125

    26463/09

    TRUFAN ANNA VASILYEVNA, 1949

    LDC, 15.09.2003

    1,410

    126

    26465/09

    KHRAMKIN NIKOLAY IVANOVICH, 1948

    1) Slovyansk Court, 22.12.1998

    2) LDC, 19.03.2002

    2,250

    127

    26466/09

    KHRISTOFOROV

    ALESKANDR SERGEYEVICH, 1941

    Slovyansk Court, 17.11.2003

    1,365

    128

    26467/09

    KHODOLEY YURIY STEPANOVICH, 1946

    Slovyansk Court, 30.10.1997

    2,460

    129

    26468/09

    CHEMERIS NINA VLADIMIROVNA, 1950

    Slovyansk Court,15.01.1998, 14.06.1999

    2,415

    130

    26470/09

    CHEREVKO ALEKSANDR IVANOVICH, 1931

    Slovyansk Court, 24.07.2000

    1,965

    131

    26471/09

    CHERKASOV VASILIY YEFREMOVICH, 1935

    Slovyansk Court, 06.10.1997

    2,460

    132

    26472/09

    CHESNOKOV VALERIY VLADIMIROVICH, 1967

    LDC, 05.03.2002

    1,680

    133

    26474/09

    CHUPRINA TAMARA NIKOLAYEVNA, 1955

    Slovyansk Court,08.09.1997, 10.04.2000

    2,475

    134

    26475/09

    SHAMRAY NINA ANDREYEVNA, 1945

    Slovyansk Court,25.11.1997

    2,445

    135

    26476/09

    SHEVCHENKO VALENTINA FROLOVNA, 1946

    Slovyansk Court,20.10.1997

    2,460

    136

    26477/09

    SHEVCHUK VASILIY NIKOLAYEVICH, 1952

    1) Slovyansk Court, 05.11.1997, 29.03.1999

    2) LDC, 13.09.2001

    2,460

    137

    26478/09

    SHEVCHENKO

    VLADIMIR ANATOLYEVICH, 1967

    Slovyansk Court, 02.10.1997

    2,475

    138

    26479/09

    SHUN NADEZHDA VALENTINOVNA, 1952

    Slovyansk Court, 17.10.1997

    2,460

    139

    26480/09

    YUDENOK TATYANA GRIGORYEVNA, 1953

    Slovyansk Court, 11.05.1999

    2,175


     


BAILII: Copyright Policy | Disclaimers | Privacy Policy | Feedback | Donate to BAILII
URL: http://www.bailii.org/eu/cases/ECHR/2012/398.html