BAILII is celebrating 24 years of free online access to the law! Would you consider making a contribution?
No donation is too small. If every visitor before 31 December gives just £1, it will have a significant impact on BAILII's ability to continue providing free access to the law.
Thank you very much for your support!
 |
[Home] [Databases] [World Law] [Multidatabase Search] [Help] [Feedback] | |
European Court of Human Rights |
||
|
You are here: BAILII >> Databases >> European Court of Human Rights >> MAKARA AND OTHERS v. UKRAINE - 40934/06 - Committee Judgment [2013] ECHR 1282 (12 December 2013) URL: http://www.bailii.org/eu/cases/ECHR/2013/1282.html Cite as: [2013] ECHR 1282 |
||
[New search] [Contents list] [Printable RTF version] [Help]
FIFTH SECTION
CASE OF MAKARA AND OTHERS v. UKRAINE
(Application no. 40934/06 and 249 other applications)
JUDGMENT
STRASBOURG
12 December 2013
This judgment is final. It may be subject to editorial revision.
In the case of Makara and others v. Ukraine,
The European Court of Human Rights (Fifth Section), sitting as a Committee composed of:
Boštjan M. Zupančič, President,
Ann Power-Forde,
Helena Jäderblom, judges,
and Stephen Phillips, Deputy Section Registrar,
Having deliberated in private on 19 November 2013,
Delivers the following judgment, which was adopted on that date:
PROCEDURE
1. The case originated in 250 applications against Ukraine lodged with the Court under Article 34 of the Convention for the Protection of Human Rights and Fundamental Freedoms (“the Convention”) by Ukrainian naionals, a company based in Ukraine and a Moldovan national, whose details are specified in the appended tables (“the applicants”).
2. The Government (“the Government”) were represented by their Agent, Mr Nazar Kulchytskyy.
3. On 25 April 2013 the applications were communicated to the Government.
4. The Moldovan Government, having been informed of their right to intervene in the proceedings in respect of the applicant in application no. 63044/11 (Article 36 § 1 of the Convention and Rule 44 of the Rules of Court), did not manifest the wish to exercise that right.
5. On 25 October 2013 the son of the applicant in application no. 75234/11 informed the Court that his father, Andriy Ivanovych Kolomiyets, had died on 24 June 2013. Mr Sergiy Andriyovych Kolomiyets expressed his wish to maintain the application of the deceased father.
THE FACTS
THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE CASE
6. On the dates set out in the appended tables domestic courts and labour disputes commissions delivered decisions according to which the applicants were entitled to various pecuniary amounts or to have certain actions taken in their favour. The decisions became final and enforceable. However, the applicants were unable to obtain the enforcement of the decisions in due time.
7. Some of the applicants also made submissions concerning factual and legal matters unrelated to the above non-enforcement issues.
THE LAW
I. AS TO THE LOCUS STANDI OF Mr SERGIY ANDRIYOVYCH KOLOMIYETS (SON OF THE APPLICANT IN APPLICATION No. 75234/11)
8. The Court notes that application no. 75234/11 concerns a property right which is in principle transferable to the heirs, and that there are next of kin of the deceased applicant who wish to pursue the application. In these circumstances the Court considers that Mr Sergiy Andriyovych Kolomiyets, the son of the deceased applicant, has standing to continue the present proceedings in his stead (see, among other authorities, Mironov v. Ukraine, no. 19916/04, § 12, 14 December 2006).
II. ALLEGED VIOLATION OF ARTICLES 6 AND 13 OF THE CONVENTION AND OF ARTICLE 1 OF PROTOCOL No. 1
9. The applicants complained about the lengthy non-enforcement of the decisions given in their favour and about the lack of effective domestic remedies in respect of those complaints. They relied on, expressly or in substance, Articles 6 § 1 and 13 of the Convention and Article 1 of Protocol No. 1.
A. Applications set out in Appendix 1
10. In view of the similarity of the applications listed in Appendix 1 in terms of the principal legal issue raised, the Court finds it appropriate to join them.
11. The Court notes that in several applications the Government made specific comments on the admissibility of the case, including that the judgment had been enforced, that the applicant had not suffered any significant disadvantage, that the applicant was not entitled to sums of money claimed, that the application was an abuse of the right of petition, that the applicants had lost interest in the case, or that the State was otherwise not responsible for the delay. The Court has considered these submissions as they have been made, notes that they are similar to submissions which have been made in previous cases and finds that, for similar or related reasons, they do not affect the outcome of the present case.
12. The Court further notes that the complaints of the applicants enumerated in Appendix 1 are not manifestly ill-founded within the meaning of Article 35 § 3 (a) of the Convention. It further notes that they are not inadmissible on any other grounds. They must therefore be declared admissible.
13. The Court finds that the domestic decisions set out in Appendix 1 were not enforced in due time, for which the State authorities were responsible.
14. Having regard to its well-established case-law on the subject (see Yuriy Nikolayevich Ivanov v. Ukraine, no. 40450/04, § §§ 56-58 and 66-70, 15 October 2009), the Court finds that in the applications listed in Appendix 1 there has been a violation of Article 6 § 1 of the Convention and Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 on account of the prolonged non-enforcement of the decisions in the applicants’ favour. It also considers that there has been a violation of Article 13 of the Convention in that the applicants did not have an effective domestic remedy to redress the damage created by such non-enforcement.
B. Applications set out in Appendix 2
15. In view of the similarity of the applications listed in Appendix 2 in terms of the principal legal issue raised, the Court finds it appropriate to join them.
1. Applications nos. 25461/10, 42826/11 and 43547/11
16. In their observations in respect of applications nos. 25461/10, 42826/11 and 43547/11 the Government submitted that the relevant domestic decisions had been fully enforced within reasonable periods of time. They claimed, in particular, that the enforcement had been completed within ten (application 25461/10) and four months (applications nos. 42826/11 and 43547/11). They noted in respect of application no. 43547/11 that as the judgment at issue had been rendered in favour of the applicant’s deceased father, the applicant could claim to be victim of the alleged violation as from 21 May 2011, the date on which the applicant had been recognized as a judgment creditor by a domestic court. The Government, therefore, maintained that these applications were manifestly ill-founded. The applicants failed to refute the Government’s contentions.
17. The Court observes that the applicant in application no. 43547/11 inherited the judgment debt on 27 January 2011 and, accordingly, he could claim to be victim of the non-enforcement from that date, with respect to violation of Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 (see Lopatyuk and Others v. Ukraine, nos. 903/05 and others § 14-15, 17 January 2008). In any event, the duration of the enforcement in his favour amounted to eight months only. The Court, therefore, agrees with the Government’s position that the length of enforcement in these three applications was not excessive and that the applications are manifestly ill-founded within the meaning of Article 35 § 3, and must be rejected pursuant to Article 35 § 4 of the Convention (see Andreyenko and Others v. Ukraine (dec.), no. 22312/03, 19 June 2007; Zbaranskaya v. Ukraine (dec.), no. 43496/02, 11 October 2005).
2. Applications nos. 32650/11, 45331/11, 71028/11 and 75042/11
18. The Government argued that in the above applications the delays in enforcement concerned the payment of relatively small awards (between UAH 38,40 (around EUR 4) in application no. 32650/11 and UAH 876 (around EUR 81) in application no. 71028/11. They contended that the applicants had not suffered a significant disadvantage in view of the pettiness of those amounts. The applicants did not argue.
19. The Court recalls that it has previously found a lack of “significant disadvantage” in the cases, where the amount in question was equal or inferior to roughly EUR 500 (see, for instance, Gururyan v. Armenia (dec.), no. 11456/05, 24 January 2012; Ștefănescu v. Romania (dec.), no. 11774/04, 12 April 2011). The Court agrees that in present cases the applicants did not suffer any significant disadvantage as a result of the non-enforcement of the judgments at issue.
20. The Court also notes that “the respect for human rights”, as defined in the Convention and the Protocols thereto, does not require examination of the present complaint on the merits, as the problem of non-enforcement of final decisions has already been addressed in the Court’s pilot judgment against Ukraine adopted in the case of Yuriy Nikolaevich Ivanov v. Ukraine (see Yuriy Nikolayevich Ivanov v. Ukraine, cited above) and in a number of other cases examined against Ukraine, which are moreover currently examined under “the well-established case-law procedure”.
21. The Court further notes that the applicants’ cases were duly considered by the domestic tribunals within the meaning of Article 35 § 3 (b) with the decisions favourable to the applicants.
22. In view of the foregoing, the Court concludes that applications nos. 32650/11, 45331/11, 71028/11 and 75042/11 should be rejected as inadmissible in accordance with Article 35 § 3 (b) of the Convention.
3. Application no. 38898/11
23. The Government submitted that according to the findings of an inquiry carried out by the Ukrainian authorities the judgment of the Zamostyanskyy District Court of Vinnytsya dated 11 December 2006 had been forged. The Court was also informed that in March 2012 criminal proceedings as to the forgery of the abovementioned judgment had been instituted. The Government also recalled that the issue of non-enforcement of the judgment of 11 December 2006 had been subject to the Court’s examination in the framework of the case of Igor Volodymyrovych Pechonka and 5 Other applications against Ukraine ([Committee], no. 3834/10, 2 April 2013), in which the applicants’ complaints had been rejected as a whole as an abuse of the right of application. The applicant did not reply to the submissions of the Government.
24. The Court comes to the same conclusions in this application and declares it inadmissible as an abuse of the right of application pursuant to Article 35 §§ 3 and 4 of the Convention.
4. Application no. 66805/11
25. The Government submitted that by the judgment of the Leninskyy District Court of Lugansk of 5 January 2005 the debtor, a local Military Enlistment Office, had been ordered to recalculate the applicant’s military pension taking into account rates of additional increases determined by the bylaws applicable at the time. They claimed that the debtor had recalculated and paid the applicant’s pension according to the above bylaws until 31 December 2007. The Government further argued that from 1 January 2008 the applicant had lost legitimate expectations as to payment of his pension in the amount envisaged by the judgment of 5 January 2005 on account of changes to legislation regulating calculation of military pension, on whose provisions the judgment at issue had been based. The Government further maintained that the applicant’s complaints were fully unsubstantiated and that he had brought his application before the Court more than 3 years after the changes to legislation. They considered that, given the above the application was manifestly ill-founded. The applicant argued.
26. The Court observes that applicant did not challenge before national courts the authorities’ refusal from 1 January 2008 to pay him the pension in the amount provided by the judgment of 5 January 2005. Accordingly, the matter whether the changes to legislation referred to by the Government were capable of justifying the termination of such payments was not subject to examination by the domestic courts. It follows that the applicant’s complaints must be rejected under Article 35 §§ 1 and 4 of the Convention for non-exhaustion of domestic remedies.
III. OTHER ALLEGED VIOLATIONS OF THE CONVENTION
27. Some of the applicants raised other complaints under the Convention, which the Court has examined carefully. In the light of all the material in its possession, and in so far as the matters complained of are within its competence, the Court finds that they do not disclose any appearance of a violation of the rights and freedoms set out in the Convention or its Protocols.
28. It follows that those complaints are manifestly ill-founded and must be rejected in accordance with Article 35 §§ 3 (a) and 4 of the Convention.
IV. APPLICATION OF ARTICLE 41 OF THE CONVENTION
29. Article 41 of the Convention provides:
“If the Court finds that there has been a violation of the Convention or the Protocols thereto, and if the internal law of the High Contracting Party concerned allows only partial reparation to be made, the Court shall, if necessary, afford just satisfaction to the injured party.”
30. In the present case, the Court considers it reasonable and equitable (see Kononova and Others v. Ukraine [Committee], no. 11770/03 and 89 other applications, § 24, 6 June 2013; Tsibulko and Others v. Ukraine [Committee], no. 65656/11 and 249 other applications, § 19, 20 June 2013; Pysarskyy and Others v. Ukraine [Committee], no. 20397/07 and 164 other applications, § 24, 20 June 2013) to award 2,000 euros (EUR) to each of the applicants in Appendix 1. This sum is to cover any pecuniary and non-pecuniary damage, as well as costs and expenses.
31. The Court further notes that the respondent State has an outstanding obligation to enforce the decisions which remain enforceable.
32. The Court considers it appropriate that the default interest rate should be based on the marginal lending rate of the European Central Bank, to which should be added three percentage points.
FOR THESE REASONS, THE COURT UNANIMOUSLY
1. Decides to join the applications set out in Appendix 1;
2. Declares admissible the complaints of the applicants, listed in Appendix 1, under Article 6 § 1 and Article 13 of the Convention and Article 1 of Protocol No. 1 about the lengthy non-enforcement of the decisions given in their favour and about the lack of effective domestic remedies in respect of those complaints and declares inadmissible the remainder of the applications;
3. Holds that there has been a violation of Article 6 § 1 of the Convention and of Article 1 of Protocol No. 1;
4. Holds that there has been a violation of Article 13 of the Convention;
5. Holds
(a) that within three months the respondent State is to enforce the domestic decisions in the applicants’ favour which remain enforceable, and is to pay EUR 2,000 (two thousand euros) to each applicant or his or her estate in the applications enumerated in Appendix 1 in respect of pecuniary and non-pecuniary damage, and costs and expenses, plus any tax that may be chargeable to the applicants on the above amounts, which are to be converted into the national currency at the rate applicable at the date of settlement;
(b) that from the expiry of the above-mentioned three months until settlement simple interest shall be payable on the above amounts at a rate equal to the marginal lending rate of the European Central Bank during the default period plus three percentage points.
6. Decides to join the applications set out in Appendix 2, and to declare them inadmissible.
Done in English, and notified in writing on 12 December 2013, pursuant to Rule 77 §§ 2 and 3 of the Rules of Court.
Stephen Phillips Boštjan M. Zupančič
Deputy Registrar President
APPENDIX 1
(admissible applications)
| APPENDIX 1 (admissible applications) | |||
| No. | Application no. and date of introduction | Applicant name date of birth place of residence | Relevant domestic decision |
| 1. | 40934/06 28/09/2006 | Larisa Nikolayevna MAKARA 31/07/1958 Vesele | Mykhaylivskyy District Court of the Zaporizhzhya Region, 18/07/1995 |
| 2. | 1912/08 24/12/2007 | Irina Vladimirovna KOSTYANIKOVA 16/03/1960 Krasnyy Luch | Krasnyy Luch Court, 18/05/2005 |
| 3. | 36173/08 30/06/2008 | Ivan Gryorovych GORDEYUK 07/10/1938 Lviv | 1) Shevchenkivskyy District Court of Lviv, 13/12/2007
2) Lviv Circuit Administrative Court, 13/10/2008
3) Lviv Administrative Court of Appeal, 02/02/2010
4) Galytskyy District Court of Lviv, 29/07/2010
5) Shevchenkivskyy District Court of Lviv, 29/07/2010 |
| 4. | 37658/09 24/06/2009 | Kateryna Sergiyivna FRANOVSKA 07/09/1956 Zhytomyr | 1) Pecherskyy District Court of Kyiv, 23/08/2005
2) Zhytomyr Circuit Administrative Court, 05/10/2007, quashed by the Higher Administrative Court on 19/07/2011
3) Zhytomyr Circuit Administrative Court, 21/11/2007 |
| 5. | 50090/09 03/08/2009 | Viktor Ivanovych MYKHAYLOVSKYY 27/09/1959 Zhytomyr | 1) Pecherskyy District Court of Kyiv, 23/08/2005
2) Zhytomyr Circuit Administrative Court, 05/10/2007, quashed by the resolution of the Higher Administrative Court of Ukraine on 19/07/2011
3) Zhytomyr Circuit Administrative Court, 21/11/2007 |
| 6. | 57108/09 15/10/2009 | Lyubov Myroslavivna BABIRAD 01/10/1965 Sambir | 1) Sambir Court, 22/04/2009
2) Sambir Court, 18/06/2009 |
| 7. | 61775/09 04/11/2009 | Aleksandr Aleksandrovich TIMOSHENKO 11/02/1982 Oleksandriya | Oleksandriya Court, 27/12/2007 |
| 8. | 36695/10 25/05/2010 | Oleksandra Fedorivna SHAGA 04/12/1951 Chernigiv | 1) Novozavodskyy District Court of Chernigiv, 18/12/2009
2) Kyiv Administrative Court of Appeal, 19/02/2009 |
| 9. | 45184/10 07/07/2010 | Oleksandr Ivanovych VLASENKO 05/11/1974 Rozsoshentsi | 1) Kyyivskyy District Court of Poltava, 30/03/2009
2) Kyyivskyy District Court of Poltava, 31/03/2010 |
| 10. | 46174/10 02/08/2010 | Valentina Pavlovna IGNATOVA 21/05/1947 Krupske, Makiyivka | Chervonogvardiyskyy District Court of Makiyivka, 23/12/2002 |
| 11. | 49967/10 17/08/2010 | Yuriy Alekseyevich USOV 07/07/1949 Kherson | Dniprovskyy District Court of Kherson, 06/07/2009, as amended by the Kherson Regional Court of Appeal, 02/12/2009 |
| 12. | 72622/10 16/11/2010 | Volodymyr Yuriyovych TKACHUK 04/08/1967 Zhytomyr | Korolyovskyy District Court of Zhytomyr, 26/09/2003 |
| 13. | 24651/11 08/04/2011 | Ivan Fedorovych PANCHENKO 16/08/1944 Tetiyiv | Tetiyiv Court, 29/11/2007 |
| 14. | 28494/11 27/04/2011 | Lidiya Grigoryevna VORONKOVA 08/01/1952 Pavlograd | Pavlograd Court, 03/11/2006, as amended by the Dnipropetrovsk Regional Court of Appeal on 10/05/2007 |
| 15. | 28950/11 28/04/2011 | Yelena Vitalyevna MASLAK 01/01/1965 Kostyantynivka | Kostyantynivka Court, 09/02/2001 |
| 16. | 32420/11 17/05/2011 | Grygoriy Ivanovych SKRYPNIK 01/01/1965 Lysychansk | 1) Labour Disputes Commission of the Remontno Mekhanichnyy Zavod, OJSC, 23/11/2004
2) Lysychansk Court, 18/02/2011 |
| 17. | 32423/11 17/05/2011 | Tetyana Ivanivna SKRYPNYK 20/01/1959 Lysychansk | 1) Labour Disputes Commission of the Remontno Mekhanichnyy Zavod, OJSC, 23/11/2004
2) Lysychansk Court, 18/02/2011 |
| 18. | 33576/11 20/05/2011 | Vladyslav Vasylyovych POTIYENKO 01/01/1965 Tetiyiv | Tetiyiv Court, 28/11/2007 |
| 19. | 35171/11 30/05/2011 | Anatoliy Filippovich KHODAK 29/08/1961 Khmelnytskyy | Military Court of the Khmelnytskyy Garrison, 23/02/2004 |
| 20. | 35400/11 17/05/2011 | Lyubov Ivanovna GAVRISH 23/05/1961 Knyagynivka | Krasnyy Luch Court, 21/06/2005 |
| 21. | 35406/11 17/05/2011 | Larisa Ivanovna RUDNEVA 28/12/1969 Vakhrusheve | Krasnyy Luch Court, 10/06/2005 |
| 22. | 35428/11 17/05/2011 | Lyudmila Petrovna LOMAKINA 05/06/1961 Krasnyy Luch | Krasnyy Luch Court, 10/08/2005 |
| 23. | 36698/11 03/06/2011 | Yaroslav Fedorovich STASYUK 06/12/1958 Sosnivka | Chervonograd Court, 22/08/2005 |
| 24. | 36932/11 09/06/2011 | Vasyl Matviyovych VITCHYNKIN 18/01/1949 Berezan | Berezan Court, 04/10/ 2007 |
| 25. | 36939/11 09/06/2011 | Nadiya Oleksiyivna VITCHYNKINA 05/03/1952 Berezan | Berezan Court, 04/10/2007 |
| 26. | 36968/11 10/06/2011 | Galyna Mykhaylivna DESNENKO 13/12/1953 Oleksandriya | Oleksandriya Court, 27/12/2007, as amended by the Dnipropetrovsk Administrative Court of Appeal, 04/11/2008 |
| 27. | 37138/11 04/06/2011 | Viktor Ananiyovych SHEIN 23/08/1936 Yakovlivka | 1) Tsentralno-Miskyy District Court of Gorlivka, 25/04/2003
2) Tsentralno-Miskyy District Court of Gorlivka, 11/03/2004 |
| 28. | 37458/11 31/05/2011 | Andriy Oleksiyovych TELESHUN 06/02/1959 Oleksandriya | Oleksandriya Court, 18/08/2009 |
| 29. | 37753/11 09/06/2011 | Stepan Yakovych POLISHCHUK 01/01/1954 Telizhentsi | Tetiyiv Court, 17/12/2007 |
| 30. | 37760/11 14/06/2011 | Gennadiy Viktorovych MATYUSHYN 28/01/1963 Zhytomyr | Korolyovskyy District Court of Zhytomyr, 13/05/2010 |
| 31. | 38132/11 11/06/2011 | Yegor Yegorovych NOVOKHATSKYY 15/03/1952 Lugansk | Zhovtnevyy District Court of Lugansk, 25/02/2010 |
| 32. | 38379/11 14/06/2011 | Rygyna Eduartivna MURGA 05/10/1931 Mazinky | Pereyaslav-Khmelnytskyy Court, 19/02/2008 |
| 33. | 38858/11 17/06/2011 | Oleksandr Mykhaylovych LOMYKO 23/07/1951 Lugansk | Artemivsk Court, 05/03/2009 |
| 34. | 38925/11 17/06/2011 | Nina Pavlivna BUBENKO 01/12/1926 Bovkun | Tarashcha Court, 31/07/2008 |
| 35. | 39240/11 10/06/2011 | Gennadiy Glebovich LATYGOVSKIY 15/01/1950 Perevalsk | Perevalsk Court, 18/09/2000 |
| 36. | 39260/11 15/06/2011 | Vasyl Oleksandrovych SHEVCHUK 01/01/1957 Sofipol | Tetiyiv Court, 29/11/2007 |
| 37. | 39269/11 03/06/2011 | Mariya Nikolayevna SAYEVSKAYA 07/05/1955 Konotop | Konotop Court, 26/11/2007 |
| 38. | 39772/11 06/06/2011 | Yuriy Stanislavovich DYUKHIN 02/03/1963 Konotop | Kharkiv Administrative Court of Appeal, 03/04/2009 |
| 39. | 39773/11 08/06/2011 | Mykhaylo Vasylovych KOTYUK 01/01/1949 Oleksandriya | 1) Oleksandriya Court, 31/03/2009
2) Oleksandriya Court, 31/03/2009 |
| 40. | 39951/11 07/06/2011 | Leonid Oleksiyovych ZHOLUD 17/05/1948 Oleksandriya | 1) Oleksandriya Court, 31/03/2009
2) Oleksandriya Court, 31/03/2009 |
| 41. | 40071/11 16/06/2011 | Ivan Mykhaylovych TARAN 18/07/1941 Khmelnytskyy | Khmelnytskyy Court, 06/03/2008 |
| 42. | 40073/11 14/06/2011 | Vladimir Kimovich ZINCHENKO 04/03/1963 Oleksandrivka | Oleksandrivka Court, 10/04/2007 |
| 43. | 40094/11 20/06/2011 | Oleksandr Vasylyovych GODUNOV 14/03/1956 Artemivsk | Artemovsk Court, 02/04/2008 |
| 44. | 41182/11 22/06/2011 | Aleksandr Nikolayevich BOYKO 02/08/1947 Dubovyazivka | Konotop Court, 24/09/2007 |
| 45. | 41293/11 24/06/2011 | Raisa Valeryanovna CHERNYKH 02/10/1956 Krasnyy Luch | Krasnyy Luch Court, 13/07/2005 |
| 46. | 41456/11 24/06/2011 | Alla Borisovna CHEREMKA 19/05/1963 Vakhrusheve | Krasnyy Luch Court, 16/05/2005. |
| 47. | 41712/11 02/07/2011 | Petro Valentynovych GRYGORYEV 04/12/1932 Kyiv | Dniprovskyy District Court of Kyiv, 25/02/2010 |
| 48. | 42261/11 21/06/2011 | Igor Volodymyrovych STRIGIN 30/07/1959 Oleksandriya | 1) Oleksandriya Court, 21/05/2009
2) Oleksandriya Court, 21/05/2009 |
| 49. | 42266/11 03/06/2011 | Igor Yaroslavovych STEFANIV 25/10/1967 Kremenchuk | 1) Avtozavodskyy District Court of Kremenchuk, 01/10/2008
2) Avtozavodskyy District Court of Kremenchuk, 13/01/2010 |
| 50. | 42270/11 01/07/2011 | Ivan Ananiyovych YARMAK 28/09/1938 Kyiv | Fastiv Court, 06/03/2008 |
| 51. | 42272/11 01/07/2011 | Oleksandr Petrovych MYKHAYLENKO 21/10/1946 Markhalivka | Fastiv Court, 05/03/2008 |
| 52. | 42316/11 01/07/2011 | Oleksandr Ivanovych GURYANOV 23/03/1934 Kyiv | Fastiv Court, 18/03/2008 |
| 53. | 42322/11 01/07/2011 | Gennadiy Grygorovych SAMKO 09/10/1936 Kyiv | Fastiv Court, 06/03/2008, quashed by the Kyiv Administrative Court of Appeal on 02/07/2013 |
| 54. | 42709/11 05/07/2011 | Oleksandr Volodymyrovych KOZLOV 16/04/1927 Zhytomyr | Zhytomyr Circuit Administrative Court, 15/10/2007 |
| 55. | 42722/11 09/06/2011 | Mykola Ivanovych KUZUB 06/03/1950 Kyiv | Kyiv City Court of Appeal, 25/08/2010 |
| 56. | 43118/11 05/07/2011 | Vasyl Stepanovych DEMENTIYENKO 27/10/1927 Zhytomyr | Zhytomyr Circuit Administrative Court, 15/10/2007 |
| 57. | 43123/11 01/07/2011 | Vitaliy Mykolayovych SVITANKO 15/11/1980 Kyiv | 1) Krasnyy Luch Court, 03/11/2005
2) Krasnyy Luch Court, 24/03/2006 |
| 58. | 43767/11 02/07/2011 | Vladimir Ilyich KOLESNYK 21/09/1948 Konotop | Konotop Court, 26/11/2007, as amended by the Kharkiv Administrative Court of Appeal on 09/12/2008 |
| 59. | 44417/11 13/07/2011 | Alla Vasylivna SOLOMKA 25/11/1973 Sarny | Rivne Circuit Administrative Court, 20/08/2008 |
| 60. | 44653/11 13/07/2011 | ENERGO, PAT Manevychi | Volyn Regional Commercial Court, 10/01/2005 |
| 61. | 44675/11 07/07/2011 | Roman Ivanovych LAZARCHUK 21/08/1969 Energodar | Energodar Court, 02/06/2010 |
| 62. | 44687/11 08/07/2011 | Olena Volodymyrivna DAVYDENKO 08/03/1980 Bilgorodka | Kyevo-Svyatoshynskyy District Court of the Kyiv Region, 06/07/2009 |
| 63. | 44694/11 07/07/2011 | Tetyana Moyseyivna MELNYK 16/03/1942 Odesa | Odesa Regional Court of Appeal, 06/06/2007 |
| 64. | 44845/11 04/07/2011 | Igor Viktorovych NABATCHYKOV 12/04/1961 Zhytomyr | Zhytomyr Circuit Administrative Court, 27/02/2009 |
| 65. | 44956/11 01/07/2011 | Yuriy Ivanovich DAVYDENKO 25/10/1968 Konotop | Konotop Court, 21/01/2009 |
| 66. | 45016/11 06/07/2011 | Tamara Prokopivna REDKINA 18/04/1936 Bobrovytsya | Bobrovytsya Court, 27/02/2002 |
| 67. | 45073/11 05/07/2011 | Sergey Vitalyevich UGRYUMOV 11/10/1960 Konotop | Konotop Court, 28/07/2010 |
| 68. | 45089/11 13/07/2011 | Semen Danylovych USENKO 21/09/1940 Zhytomyr | Bogunskyy District Court of Zhytomyr, 26/04/2010 |
| 69. | 45110/11 15/07/2011 | Mariya Mykolayivna LOZIVSKA 26/01/1944 Ploske | 1) Tarashcha Court, 17/06/2008
2) Tarashcha Court, 17/06/2008 |
| 70. | 45672/11 12/07/2011 | Sergey Vladimirovich SEMAKIN 02/04/1958 Oleksandriya | Oleksandriya Court, 20/12/2007, as amended by the Dnipropetrovsk Administrative Court of Appeal on 04/11/2008 |
| 71. | 45681/11 04/05/2011 | Vladimir Ivanovich BATLUK 01/10/1949 Konotop | Konotop Court, 26/01/2009 |
| 72. | 45729/11 13/07/2011 | Olena Mykhaylivna MYKHAYLYTSKA 17/09/1975 Sarny | Rivne Circuit Administrative Court, 20/08/2008 |
| 73. | 45885/11 08/07/2011 | Andriy Dmytrovych DZIKUNSKYY 01/01/1954 Tetiyiv | Tetiyiv Court , 26/11/2007 |
| 74. | 46157/11 15/07/2011 | Yuriy Valeriyovych POLISHCHUK 01/01/1985 Tetiyiv | Tetiyiv Court, 26/11/2007 |
| 75. | 46328/11 08/07/2011 | Vitaliy Viktorovych GUSYEV 11/03/1961 Novograd-Volynskyy | 1) Zhytomyr Circuit Administrative Court, 07/08/2007
2) Zhytomyr Circuit Administrative Court, 15/08/2007 |
| 76. | 46450/11 17/06/2011 | Ivan Semenovych BOYKO 02/04/1931 Khmelnytskyy
Ida Sergiyivna FEDYAYEVA 17/10/1926 Khmelnytskyy | Khmelnytskyy Circuit Administrative Court, 01/12/2008 |
| 77. | 46655/11 19/07/2011 | Vitaliy Mykolayovych DATSKO 08/03/1969 Kalynivka | Zamostyanskyy District Court of Vinnytsya, 07/12/2006 |
| 78. | 46843/11 22/07/2011 | Petro Andriyovych OSYKA 01/01/1958 Sofipol | Tetyiv Court, 29/11/2007 |
| 79. | 47231/11 20/07/2011 | Sergiy Grygorovych SHLYAKHTYCHENKO 01/01/1965 Tetiyiv | Tetiyiv Court, 06/02/2008 |
| 80. | 47388/11 21/07/2011 | Yuriy Grygorovych CHUZHA 07/01/1952 Uzhgorod | 1) Uzhgorod Court, 01/03/2007
2) Uzhgorod Court, 14/05/2007 |
| 81. | 47472/11 25/06/2011 | Nina Petrivna MOZGOVA 19/01/1947 Svitlovodsk | Svitlovodsk Court, 04/10/2007 |
| 82. | 47629/11 25/07/2011 | Oksana Anatoliyivna SOBOLEVSKA 15/01/1978 Poltava | Poltava Regional Court of Appeal, 31/08/2010 |
| 83. | 47792/11 22/07/2011 | Lyubov Pavlovna GURSKAYA 31/10/1953 Kostyantynivka | Kostyantynivka Court, 23/11/2004 |
| 84. | 47873/11 22/07/2011 | Andrey Aleksandrovich FILATOV 23/12/1980 Kostyantynivka | Kostyantynivka Court, 03/03/2003 |
| 85. | 47887/11 22/07/2011 | Irina Aleksandrovna KOLESNIKOVA 17/03/1979 Illicha | Labour Disputes Commission of “Zavod Avtosklo", State Enterprise, 19/03/2001 |
| 86. | 47899/11 22/07/2011 | Lyubov Vladimirovna LUKINA 04/06/1948 Kostyantynivka | Kostyantynivka Court, 17/09/2002 |
| 87. | 47910/11 22/07/2011 | Yelena Vladimirovna TOLOKONINA 05/07/1958 Kostyantynivka | Kostyantynivka Court, 18/02/2002 |
| 88. | 47921/11 22/07/2011 | Irina Viktorovna SVINTSOVA 03/05/1974 Kostyantynivka | Kostyantynivka Court, 19/11/2004 |
| 89. | 47932/11 22/07/2011 | Viktoriya Petrovna MIROSHNICHENKO 24/04/1972 Kostyantynivka | Kostyantynivka Court, 05/04/2001 |
| 90. | 47979/11 22/07/2011 | Valeriy Fedorovich SHOSTAK 17/03/1955 Kostyantynivka | Kostyantynivka Court, 15/06/2001 |
| 91. | 48008/11 22/07/2011 | Olga Petrovna KRASILINA 20/04/1957 Kostyantynivka | 1) Kostyantynivka Court, 08/04/2003
2) Kostyantynivka Court, 08/04/2003 |
| 92. | 48042/11 22/07/2011 | Nikolay Naumovich TOPCHIY 08/08/1935 Kostyantynivka | Kostyantynivka Court, 27/02/1998 |
| 93. | 48059/11 22/07/2011 | Mikhail Kuzmich PAVLISHCHEV 19/02/1947 Kostyantynivka | Kostyantynivka Court, 21/06/2001 |
| 94. | 48080/11 22/07/2011 | Irina Mikhaylovna KOZUB 26/09/1961 Kostyantynivka | Kostyantynivka Court, 30/10/2001 |
| 95. | 48109/11 22/07/2011 | Natalya Vasilyevna ALTUKHOVA 08/03/1957 Kostyantynivka | 1) Labour Disputes Commission of “Zavod Avtosklo", State Enterprise, 1997
2) Labour Disputes Commission of “Zavod Avtosklo", State Enterprise, 2001 |
| 96. | 48121/11 22/07/2011 | Irina Anatolyevna KAVERINA 02/12/1967 Kostyantynivka | Kostyantynivka Court, 30/03/2001 |
| 97. | 48148/11 22/07/2011 | Inna Viktorovna BONDYUK 17/10/1977 Kostyantynivka | Kostyantynivka Court, 25/01/2001 |
| 98. | 48156/11 22/07/2011 | Natalya Sergeyevna KANDYBKA 25/06/1963 Kostyantynivka | Kostyantynivka Court, 18/02/2002 |
| 99. | 48162/11 23/07/2011 | Viktor Nikolayevich GAYVORONSKIY 15/09/1949 Vakhrusheve | 1) Krasnyy Luch Court, 26/10/2009
2) Krasnyy Luch Court, 26/10/2009
3) Krasnyy Luch Court, 26/10/2009 |
| 100. | 48167/11 08/07/2011 | Pavlo Mykhaylovych LYTVYN 08/06/1961 Chernigiv | Chernigiv Circuit Administrative Court, 14/07/2008 |
| 101. | 48204/11 22/07/2011 | Yelena Viktorovna ANENKOVA 08/10/1960 Kostyantynivka | Kostyantynivka Court, 27/12/2002 |
| 102. | 48218/11 22/07/2011 | Lyudmila Mikhaylovna DROKINA 28/12/1946 Kostyantynivka | Kostyantynivka Court, 19/12/2000 |
| 103. | 48229/11 22/07/2011 | Nataliya Aleksandrovna SAMOYLOVA 23/10/1975 Kostyantynivka | Kostyantynivka Court, 27/08/1998 |
| 104. | 48248/11 22/07/2011 | Georgiy Timofeyevich NESTERENKO 23/08/1939 Kostyantynivka | 1) Labour Disputes Commission of the Ukrayinskyy Naukovo-Doslidnyy Instytut Skla, State Enterprise, 05/02/2007
2) Labour Disputes Commission of the Ukrayinskyy Naukovo-Doslidnyy Instytut Skla, State Enterprise, 03/02/2009
3 Labour Disputes Commission of the Ukrayinskyy Naukovo-Doslidnyy Instytut Skla, State Enterprise, 06/01/2010
4) Labour Disputes Commission of the Ukrayinskyy Naukovo-Doslidnyy Instytut Skla, State Enterprise, 19/10/2010 |
| 105. | 48261/11 22/07/2011 | Vladimir Mikhaylovich LAGUTCHEV 10/07/1956 Kostyantynivka | 1) Labour Disputes Commission of “Zavod Avtosklo", State Enterprise, 1998
2) Kostyantynivka Court, 13/01/2003 |
| 106. | 48270/11 22/07/2011 | Veniamin Ivanovich NOVIKOV 12/09/1937 Kostyantynivka | 1) Labour Disputes Commission of “Zavod Avtosklo", State Enterprise, 1998
2) Labour Disputes Commission of “Zavod Avtosklo", State Enterprise, 2001 |
| 107. | 48280/11 22/07/2011 | Oleg Aleksandrovich MAKEYEV 30/07/1941 Kostyantynivka | Kostyantynivka Court, 06/09/2002 |
| 108. | 48291/11 19/07/2011 | Oksana Stepanivna ROMANYUK 28/01/1976 Sokal | Sokal Court, 26/06/2009, as amended by judgment of Lviv Regional Administrative Court, 18/01/2011 |
| 109. | 48354/11 22/07/2011 | Ivan Mikhaylovich CHEREVATENKO 01/06/1958 Kostyantynivka | Labour Disputes Commission of “Zavod Avtosklo", State Enterprise, 2001 |
| 110. | 50547/11 05/08/2011 | Sergiy Anatoliyovych SEMENCHENKO 09/05/1961 Lugansk | 1) Artemivskyy District Court of Lugansk, 21/11/2008
2) Artemivskyy District Court of Lugansk, 11/12/2008 |
| 111. | 53745/11 15/08/2011 | Grygoriy Mykhaylovych TROYANOVSKYY 22/01/1957 Novoselytsya | Khotyn Court, 10/08/2007 |
| 112. | 54166/11 12/07/2011 | Alla Mykolayivna ZAVOROTNYA 30/09/1974 Svitlovodsk | Svitlovodsk Court, 01/10/2010 |
| 113. | 54753/11 03/08/2011 | Volodymyr Anatoliyovych CHICHIL 13/06/1962 Poltava | Kyiv Circuit Administrative Court, 05/03/2010 |
| 114. | 54758/11 03/08/2011 | Sergiy Yuriyovych MARTYEV 05/10/1960 Poltava | Kyiv City Circuit Administrative Court, 01/03/2010, quashed by the same court on 08/10/2012 |
| 115. | 56282/11 30/08/2011 | Anatoliy Anatolyevich AZARDOVICH 26/12/1958 Simferopol | Zaliznychnyy District Court of Simferopol, 30/10/2007, as amended by the Higher Administrative Court of Ukraine on 09/02/2012 |
| 116. | 59128/11 29/08/2011 | Oleksandr Mykolayovych KVASHA 01/01/1964 Tetiyiv | Tetiyiv Court, 06/12/2007 |
| 117. | 59135/11 12/09/2011 | Lyudmyla Volodymyrivna REDCHYTS 29/12/1979 Gunychi | Ovruch Court, 02/11/2009 |
| 118. | 59154/11 12/09/2011 | Kseniya Volodymyrivna KOVALCHUK 19/09/1975 Zarichchya | Ovruch Court, 09/12/2009 |
| 119. | 59259/11 14/09/2011 | Lyudmyla Fedorivna PASYUK 24/12/1970 Ovruch | Ovruch Court, 25/05/2009 |
| 120. | 59277/11 15/09/2011 | Mykhaylo Ivanovych YEGORCHENKOV 11/02/1957 Donetsk | 1) Kuybyshevskyy District Court of Donetsk, 29/05/2009
2) Kuybyshevskyy District Court of Donetsk, 17/08/2010 |
| 121. | 59340/11 09/09/2011 | Volodymyr Dorofiyovych ZAGORUYKO 01/01/1951 Tetiyiv | Tetiyiv Court, 06/12/2007 |
| 122. | 59394/11 13/09/2011 | Oleksandr Ivanovych TYMOSHENKO 03/08/1962 Vasylkiv | Vasylkiv Court 20/12/2010 |
| 123. | 59545/11 14/09/2011 | Tofilya Petrivna KOBERSKA 22/01/1956 Shumsk | 1) Lviv Administrative Court of Appeal of 23/02/2009, as amended by judgment of the Higher Administrative Court of 30/09/2009
2) Lviv Administrative Court of Appeal, 15/09/2011 |
| 124. | 59579/11 10/09/2011 | Volodymyr Yuriyovych MELNYK 23/02/1934 Kyiv | Solomyanskyy District Court of Kyiv, 09/11/2009 |
| 125. | 59592/11 13/09/2011 | Galyna Gavrylivna SAVENKO 03/01/1938 Shchaslyve | Boryspil Court, 18/12/2007 |
| 126. | 60160/11 17/09/2011 | Vasyl Vasylyovych BURKO 13/08/1957 Derevnya | Chervonograd Court, 04/11/2005 |
| 127. | 61240/11 01/09/2011 | Vladimir Leonidovich GRISHANKOV 15/01/1956 Dniprodzerzhynsk | Dniprovskyy District Court of Dniprodzerzhynsk, 12/10/2010 |
| 128. | 61260/11 22/09/2011 | Mykola Yevdokymovych BUZYNOVSKYY 14/06/1940 Tarashcha | Tarashcha Court, 13/02/2008 |
| 129. | 62605/11 27/09/2011 | Volodymyr Oleksiyovych KROKHMAL 01/01/1951 Tetiyiv | Tetiyiv Court, 26/11/2007 |
| 130. | 62840/11 28/09/2011 | Vladimir Nikolayevich KISHKINOV 11/02/1956 Kryvyy Rig | Shyroke Court of Dnipropetrovsk Region, 22/07/2010 |
| 131. | 62866/11 27/09/2011 | Sergey Leonidovich BOBROV 14/03/1958 Ovruch | Ovruch Court, 02/09/2009 |
| 132. | 62991/11 21/09/2011 | Ivan Ivanovych VOLYK 06/10/1949 Zaporizhzhya | Komunarskyy District Court of Zaporizhzhya, 03/02/2006 |
| 133. | 63044/11 19/09/2011 | Semen Nikolayevich KAPSHUK 16/06/1958 Dezgmyzha | Bolgrad Court, 18/08/2006 |
| 134. | 63112/11 23/09/2011 | Oleksandr Viktorovych KORNUS 15/05/1967 Gorodyshche | Kyiv Administrative Court of Appeal, 02/02/2010 |
| 135. | 63514/11 21/09/2011 | Oleksandr Volodymyrovych KUZNETSOV 01/01/1938 Tetiyiv | Tetiyiv Court, 29/11/2007 |
| 136. | 63788/11 30/09/2011 | Gasanag Guseyn Ogly AGAYEV 02/07/1957 Debaltseve | 1) Debaltseve Court, 16/07/2002
2) Debaltseve Cour, 21/03/2008 |
| 137. | 63999/11 15/09/2011 | Volodymyr Mykhaylovych BARANOVSKYY 11/02/1958 Ovruch | Zhytomyr Circuit Administrative Court, 30/07/208 |
| 138. | 64002/11 16/09/2011 | Galyna Ivanivna BARANOVSKA 27/05/1961 Ovruch | Zhytomyr Circuit Administrative Court, 30/07/2008 |
| 139. | 64008/11 04/10/2011 | Natalya Sergeyevna BOBROVA 13/08/1958 Ovruch | 1) Ovruch Court of Zhytomyr Region, 24/03/2010
2) Ovruch Court, 02/09/2009 |
| 140. | 64074/11 30/09/2011 | Viktor Nikolayevich PAVLICHENKO 26/04/1953 Sevastopol | 1) Leninskyy District Court of Sevastopol, 9/12/2008
2) Leninskyy District Court of Sevastopol, 16/12/2008
3) Leninskyy District Court of Sevastopol, 6/07/2009 |
| 141. | 64346/11 22/09/2011 | Sergey Mikhaylovich SHESHKIN 14/12/1969 Donetsk | Proletarskyy District Court of Donetsk, 19/11/2008 |
| 142. | 64767/11 22/09/2011 | Nina Gavrylivna KRASNOKUTSKA 16/08/1962 Zhytomyr
Nina Gavrylivna KRASNOKUTSKA 24/04/1951 Zhytomyr | 1st applicant: 1) Bogunskyy District Court of Zhytomyr, 22/03/2010
2nd applicant: 2) Bogunskyy District Court of Zhytomyr, 18/03/2010
both applicants 3) Bogunskyy District Court of Zhytomyr, 15/11/2010
both applicants 4) Bogunskyy District Court of Zhytomyr, 15/06/2011 |
| 143. | 65863/11 29/09/2011 | Nikolay Mikhaylovich DYMCHENKO 03/02/1956 Vakhrusheve | Krasnyy Luch Court, 16/05/2005 |
| 144. | 66389/11 20/09/2011 | Mykhaylo Ivanovych MAGUSHYNETS 20/11/1933 Makariv | Makarivka Court of Kyiv Region, 31/05/2010 |
| 145. | 66429/11 18/10/2011 | Oleksandr Oleksandrovych POLISHCHUK 31/05/1952 Tarashcha | 1) Tarashcha Court,13/12/2007
2) Tarashcha Court, 28/05/2010 |
| 146. | 66538/11 18/10/2011 | Ganna Oleksandrivna POLISHCHUK 05/03/1923 Tarashcha | 1) Tarashcha Court,18/01/2008
2) Tarashcha Court, 31/05/2010 |
| 147. | 66648/11 13/10/2011 | Viktor Gotgoldovych GAUS 18/08/1951 Kramatorsk | Kramatorsk Court, 29/04/2009 |
| 148. | 66650/11 13/10/2011 | Volodymyr Ivanovych SHESTAKOV 03/01/1959 Kramatorsk | Kramatorsk Court, 28/05/2009 |
| 149. | 66672/11 18/10/2011 | Olga Matviyivna MAKAROVA 10/07/1925 Novograd-Volynskyy | Zhytomyr Circuit Administrative Court, 11/09/2008 |
| 150. | 66704/11 14/10/2011 | Anatoliy Mykolayovych LEVKIVSKYY 07/11/1959 Levkovychi | Ovruch Court, 29/10/2010 |
| 151. | 66715/11 14/10/2011 | Mykola Leonidovych SHVAB 21/09/1961 Poliske | 1) Ovruch Court, 11/08/2009
2) Ovruch Court, 6/09/2010 |
| 152. | 66842/11 29/09/2011 | Valentina Anatolyevna PUKHALSKAYA 05/12/1957 Knyagynivka | Krasnyy Luch Court, 18/07/2005 |
| 153. | 66850/11 29/09/2011 | Yelena Gennadyevna KOROVINA 23/06/1977 Vakhrusheve | Krasnyy Luch Court, 01/06/2005 |
| 154. | 66903/11 29/09/2011 | Natalya Borisovna MIROSHNICHENKO 13/02/1971 Knyagynivka | Krasnyy Luch Court, 11/10/2007 |
| 155. | 66923/11 06/10/2011 | Sergey Mikhaylovich BORISENKO 07/04/1976 Vakhrusheve | Krasnyy Luch Court, 16/06/2005 |
| 156. | 66933/11 06/10/2011 | Andrey Vasilyevich IVANOV 25/10/1972 Vakhrusheve | Krasnyy Luch Court, 16/05/2005 |
| 157. | 66961/11 24/05/2011 | Nikolay Andreyevich ZAKHARENKO 13/12/1946 Artemivsk | 1) Donetsk Regional Court of Appeal, 20/08/2010
2) Artemivsk Court, 02/09/2010 |
| 158. | 67391/11 20/09/2011 | Sergiy Matviyovych KOVALCHUK 07/11/1962 Gorodets | Ovruch Court, 23/07/2010 |
| 159. | 67396/11 20/09/2011 | Leonid Romanovych ROSLYK 21/09/1967 Bigun | Ovruch Court, 15/05/2009 |
| 160. | 67399/11 20/09/2011 | Tamara Mykhaylivna ROSLYK 03/10/1968 Bigun | Ovruch Court, 15/05/2009 |
| 161. | 67769/11 24/10/2011 | Georgiy Lukych KRAMCHANYN 17/09/1955 Ovruch | Ovruch Court, 07/07/2009 |
| 162. | 67774/11 24/10/2011 | Olga Dmytrivna KRAMCHANIN 17/09/1956 Ovruch | Ovruch Court, 03/11/2009 |
| 163. | 68201/11 26/10/2011 | Lyubov Grygorivna MYROSHNICHENKO 25/09/1966 Korsun-Shevchenkivskyy | Cherkasy Regional Court of Appeal, 11/11/2010 |
| 164. | 68229/11 24/10/2011 | Arkadiy Leonidovich MALEYEV 19/10/1931 Donetsk | Kyyivskyy District Court of Donetsk, 24/11/2008 |
| 165. | 68349/11 25/10/2011 | Valentyn Mykolayovych GARASHCHENKO 02/10/1952 Cherkasy | Cherkassy Regional Commercial Court, 21/09/2009, as amended by the Kyiv Interregional Commercial Court of Appeal, 14/12/2009 |
| 166. | 68416/11 21/10/2011 | Alla Ivanivna KUZNETSOVA 03/01/1942 Sverdlovsk | Sverdlovsk Court of Lugansk Region, 20/11/2001 |
| 167. | 68437/11 25/10/2011 | Oksana Sergiyivna VOYTEVYCH 18/02/1987 Ovruch | 1) Ovruch Court, 09/09/2009
2) Ovruch Court, 29/10/2009 |
| 168. | 68597/11 24/10/2011 | Viktor Mykolayovych BARZDUN 27/02/1956 Kramatorsk | Kramatorsk Court, 26/10/2009 |
| 169. | 68606/11 14/10/2011 | Volodymyr Oleksandrovych VARFOLOMEYEV 11/12/1950 Lugansk | Leninskyy District Court of Lugansk, 18/11/2008 |
| 170. | 68899/11 25/10/2011 | Volodymyr Semenovych KYRYCHENKO 25/05/1925 Letychiv | Letychiv Court, 12/07/2010 |
| 171. | 68931/11 06/10/2011 | Tatyana Ilyinichna RASHKOVA 14/06/1950 Vakhrusheve | Krasnyy Luch Court, 13/05/2005 |
| 172. | 68949/11 28/10/2011 | Igor Romanovych PASTUSHOK 31/03/1961 Ovruch | Ovruch Court, 26/05/2009 |
| 173. | 68957/11 06/10/2011 | Marina Leonidovna GORBAN 11/08/1980 Vakhrusheve | Krasnyy Luch Court, 21/06/2005 |
| 174. | 69017/11 27/10/2011 | Mariya Ivanivna AVRAMCHUK 07/12/1955 Lyubarka | Narodychi Court, 12/07/2010 |
| 175. | 69048/11 28/10/2011 | Vadym Igorovych KULYABA 18/11/1959 Kramatorsk | Kramatorsk Court, 10/09/2008 |
| 176. | 69088/11 27/10/2011 | Vasyl Safronovych AVRAMCHUK 15/08/1952 Lyubarka | 1) Narodychi Court, 01/10/2009
2) Narodychi Court, 12/07/2010 |
| 177. | 69333/11 28/10/2011 | Vitaliy Oleksiyovych KHOMIK 15/08/1963 Zhovtneve | Volyn Regional Court of Appeal, 5/11/2010 |
| 178. | 69422/11 03/11/2011 | Lybov Mykolayivna TSRYTSYNA 28/11/1964 Romny | Romny Court, 03/04/2008 |
| 179. | 69533/11 18/10/2011 | Nina Pylypivna TROKHYMETS 12/05/1931 Gostynne | Vinnytsya Circuit Administrative Court, 20/12/2007 |
| 180. | 70004/11 31/10/2011 | Volodymyr Orestovych GORNYTSKYY 12/05/1944 Sambir | Sambir Court, 05/06/1996 |
| 181. | 70021/11 04/11/2011 | Vera Nikolayevna IVAKINA 13/10/1952 Lugansk | Donetsk Administrative Court of Appeal, 13/03/2009 |
| 182. | 70084/11 04/11/2011 | Sergey Nikolayevich SHARYY 30/11/1969 Lugansk | Lugansk Circuit Administrative Court, 16/04/2009 |
| 183. | 70156/11 01/11/2011 | Alla Aleksandrovna GOLODNYUK 01/01/1963 Kripenske | Lugansk Regional Court of Appeal, 13/12/2010 |
| 184. | 70369/11 04/11/2011 | Boris Anatolyevich SHUKAYEV 15/05/1962 Chervonopartyzansk | 1) Sverdlovsk Court, 6/05/2008
2) Sverdlovsk Court, 16/04/2009 |
| 185. | 70432/11 28/10/2011 | Yuriy Vasylyovych FEDOROV 19/08/1939 Khmelnytskyy | Khmelnytskyy Court, 10/04/2009 |
| 186. | 70436/11 01/11/2011 | Nina Semenovna SHYBALKINA 01/01/1948 Krasnyy Luch | Krasnyy Luch Court, 30/04/2010 |
| 187. | 70472/11 04/11/2011 | Oleg Gennadiyovych KYSELYOV 24/10/1964 Simferopol | Zheleznodorozhnyy District Court of Simferopol, 19/01/2005 |
| 188. | 70503/11 01/11/2011 | Nikolay Stepanovich TUPAKHIN 18/04/1957 Lugansk | 1) Zhovtnevyy District Court of Lugansk, 7/05/2009
2) Zhovtnevyy District Court of Lugansk, 7/05/2009 |
| 189. | 70695/11 05/09/2011 | Vladimir Andreyevich LOGVINENKO 20/05/1955 Lugansk | 1) Zhovtnevyy District Court of Lugansk, 27/05/2009
2) Lugansk Regional Court of Appeal, 29/07/2010 |
| 190. | 70811/11 10/11/2011 | Nina Ivanovna GRUY 11/11/1952 Maloorlivka | Krasnyy Luch Court, 16/06/2005 |
| 191. | 70860/11 10/11/2011 | Yuriy Sergeyevich RUMPA 14/03/1949 Donetsk | Krasnyy Luch Court, 16/10/2002 |
| 192. | 70880/11 10/11/2011 | Larisa Leonidovna ROMANINA 10/07/1951 Vakhrusheve | Krasnyy Luch Court, 15/06/2005 |
| 193. | 70994/11 04/11/2011 | Galyna Ivanivna MOSHKIVSKA 05/10/1948 Ovruch | Zhytomyr Circuit Administrative Court, 24/02/2009 |
| 194. | 71232/11 06/11/2011 | Nadezhda Ivanovna VASILENKO 05/05/1933 Novograd-Volynskyy | Novograd-Volynskyy Court, 9/02/2011 |
| 195. | 71755/11 07/11/2011 | Natalya Nikolayevna MARKOVSKAYA 15/06/1974 Simferopol | Kyyivskyy District Court of Simferopol, 03/07/2008 as amended by the Higher Administrative Court on 18/11/2010 |
| 196. | 72423/11 18/11/2011 | Grygoriy Oleksiyovych KRASNOKUTSKYY 06/05/1950 Nova Vodolaga | Kharkiv Regional Commercial Court, 02/09/2009 |
| 197. | 72821/11 14/11/2011 | Mykhaylo Mykolayovych KOVAL 17/11/1954 Tarashcha | Tarashcha Court, 13/12/2007 |
| 198. | 72824/11 14/11/2011 | Olga Fedorivna KOVAL 29/03/1955 Tarashcha | 1) Tarashcha Court, 27/12/2007
2) Tarashcha Court, 02/02/2011 as amended by the judgment of the Kyiv Administrative Court of Appeal of 15/11/2011 |
| 199. | 73593/11 22/11/2011 | Valentyna Ivanivna MISHCHENKOVA 05/01/1956 Ostiv | Ovruch Court, 15/07/2009 |
| 200. | 73629/11 22/11/2011 | Ivan Vasylyovych DZYAKHAR 01/01/1955 Bila Tserkva | 1) Bila Tserkva Court, 30/09/2008
2) Bila Tserkva Court, 08/02/2011
3) Bila Tserkva Court, 12/07/2011
4) Bila Tserkva Court, 13/07/2011 |
| 201. | 73695/11 22/11/2011 | Volodymyr Mykhaylovych MISHCHENKOV 31/07/1953 Ostiv | Ovruch Court, 01/07/2010 |
| 202. | 73851/11 17/11/2011 | Lyubov Vasylivna TYSHKOVETS 20/10/1943 Stepan | Sarny Court, 26/08/2003 |
| 203. | 74168/11 19/11/2011 | Lyudmila Aleksandrovna TIMOSHENKO 18/08/1969 Vakhrusheve | Krasnyy Luch Court, 12/05/2010 |
| 204. | 74173/11 19/11/2011 | Lyudmila Valentinovna MOMRIK 19/10/1959 Vakhrusheve | Krasnyy Luch Court, 12/05/2010 |
| 205. | 74178/11 19/11/2011 | Nina Ivanovna MEDVED 11/09/1956 Krasnyy Luch | Krasnyy Luch Court, 12/05/2010 |
| 206. | 74183/11 19/11/2011 | Natalya Nikolayevna BYCHEK 25/01/1964 Vakhrusheve | Krasny Luch Court, 12/05/2010 |
| 207. | 74293/11 25/11/2011 | Nina Mykhaylivna NETYCHAY 01/05/1925 Khmelnytskyy | Khmelnytskyy Circuit Administrative Court, 27/11/2008 |
| 208. | 74386/11 25/11/2011 | Zoya Oleksandrivna KRYVORUCHENKO 25/01/1925 Khmelnytskyy | Khmelnytskyy Court, 06/03/2008 |
| 209. | 74405/11 23/11/2011 | Vasyl Andriyovych KOVTUNOVYCH 25/01/1954 Ovruch | Ovruch Court, 26/05/2009 |
| 210. | 74416/11 28/11/2011 | GRUPA KOMPANIY SODRUZHESTVO, TOV Kherson | Kyiv Commercial Court, 07/08/2007 |
| 211. | 74419/11 25/11/2011 | Viktor Andreyevich DIVINSKIY 05/02/1951 Ovruch | 1) Ovruch Court, 29/04/2009 as amended by the Zhytomyr Regional Court of Appeal on 15/03/2012
2) Ovruch Court, 08/07/2009
3) Ovruch Court, 31/08/2009 |
| 212. | 74422/11 25/11/2011 | Mariya Vladimirovna DIVINSKAYA 28/06/1954 Ovruch | 1) Zhytomyr Circuit Administrative Court, 13/02/2009
2) Ovruch Court, 18/02/2009 |
| 213. | 75066/11 25/11/2011 | Dmitriy Gavrilovich TSURENKO 14/10/1939 Nova Kakhovka | Kherson Circuit Administrative Court, 17/09/2009 |
| 214. | 75127/11 26/11/2011 | Mykola Vasylovych PERESADA 01/01/1944 Galayky | Tetiyiv Court, 28/01/2008 |
| 215. | 75135/11 22/11/2011 | Rayisa Mykolayivna VOYTEVYCH 09/02/1963 Ovruch | 1) Ovruch Court, 23/06/2009
2) Ovruch Court, 16/07/2010 |
| 216. | 75234/11 25/11/2011 | Andriy Ivanovych KOLOMIYETS 01/01/1957 Tetiyiv | Tetiyiv Court, 26/05/2008 |
| 217. | 75253/11 16/08/2011 | Andriy Sergiyovych VOYTEVYCH 08/10/1982 Ovruch | Ovruch Court, 25/03/2010 |
| 218. | 75437/11 02/12/2011 | Nataliya Viktorovna SMIRNOVA 17/04/1975 Ovruch | Ovruch Court, 12/05/2009 |
| 219. | 75474/11 26/11/2011 | Petro Pavlovych ZHOVNIR 16/07/1943 Chervonograd | Chervonograd Court, 27/10/2006 |
| 220. | 75796/11 01/12/2011 | Nataliya Petrivna BARANOVSKA 25/10/1980 Ovruch | Zhytomyr Circuit Administrative Court, 10/02/2009 |
| 221. | 76499/11 05/12/2011 | Valentyna Ivanivna TURBAL 20/08/1959 Ovruch | Zhytomyr Circuit Administrative Court, 13/11/2008 as amended by the Kyiv Administrative Court of Appeal on 22/12/2009 |
| 222. | 76530/11 05/12/2011 | Galyna Petrivna PYLYPCHUK 24/11/1951 Ovruch | Ovruch Court, 15/09/2010 |
| 223. | 76611/11 05/12/2011 | Anatoliy Ivanovych ALYEYNIKOV 15/11/1937 Lugansk | Leninskyy District Court of Lugansk, 04/11/2009 |
| 224. | 76773/11 07/12/2011 | Nataliya Mykolayivna KOVTUNOVYCH 24/10/1964 Ovruch | 1) Zhytomyr Circuit Administrative Court, 05/03/2009
2) Ovruch Court, 16/08/2010 |
| 225. | 76821/11 03/12/2011 | Yuriy Andriyovych TITOV 08/09/1951 Shyrokyy | Lugansk Circuit Administrative Court, 05/09/2008 |
| 226. | 77089/11 01/12/2011 | Vera Konstantinovna PAPUSH 20/02/1942 Mariupol | Zhovtnevyy District Court of Mariupol, 31/08/2010 |
| 227. | 77108/11 08/12/2011 | Vasyl Oleksandrovych SAVCHUK 19/10/1974 Lystvyn | Ovruch Court, 23/02/2010 |
| 228. | 77132/11 29/11/2011 | Volodymyr Gnatovych KHALEPA 26/07/1947 Novograd-Volynskyy | 1) Zhytomyr Circuit Administrative Court, 13/03/2008
2) Zhytomyr Circuit Administrative Court, 14/08/2008 |
| 229. | 77147/11 06/12/2011 | Vitaliy Mykolayovych VASYANOVYCH 19/09/1976 Korosten | 1) Korosten Court, 23/12/2009
2) Korosten Court, 26/02/2010
3) Korosten Court, 25/05/2010 |
| 230. | 77325/11 06/12/2011 | Lidiya Opanasivna YEGOROVA 30/09/1958 Kaniv | 1) Kaniv Court, 04/02/2008
2) Kaniv Court, 24/03/2008
3) Kaniv Court, 28/12/2009
4) Kaniv Court, 18/04/2011 |
| 231. | 77535/11 07/12/2011 | Tamara Viktorovna KRIVONOS 01/01/1938 Sevastopol | Sevastopol Circuit Administrative Court, 27/01/2010 |
| 232. | 77536/11 28/11/2011 | Volodymyr Vitsentiyovych YUZEFOVYCH 28/03/1971 Kyiv | Shevchenkivskyy District Court of Kyiv, 19/02/2010 |
| 233. | 77543/11 08/12/2011 | Leonid Yuriyovych KOTSERUBA 27/04/1959 Orativ | Vinnytsya Circuit Administrative Court, 17/08/2007 |
| 234. | 78821/11 09/12/2011 | Yevgena Dmytrivna VASYLYEVA 07/11/1926 Khmelnytskyy | Khmelnytskyy Court, 05/12/2008 |
| 235. | 78914/11 09/12/2011 | Igor Yaroslavovych SHEVCHENKO 16/04/1964 Drogobych | 1) Drogobych Court, 16/03/2006
2) Drogobych Court, 29/12/2010 |
| 236. | 2643/12 21/12/2011 | Lidiya Mykolayivna MOGYLEVETS 05/10/1957 Ovruch | Ovruch Court, 17/02/2009 |
| 237. | 23972/12 19/04/2012 | Vasyl Semenovych POTAPCHUK 26/06/1951 Vasyshcheve | 1) Kharkiv District Court of Kharkiv Region, 20/04/2010
2) Kharkiv District Court of Kharkiv Region, 31/05/2011
3) Kharkiv District Court of Kharkiv Region, 30/09/2011 |
| 238. | 24061/12 12/04/2012 | Oleksandr Pavlovych GRYGORENKO 12/04/1958 Zaporizhzhya | Leninskyy District Court of Zaporizhzhya, 28/01/2011 |
| 239. | 27160/12 29/04/2012 | Lyubov Ivanivna KOSTENKO 04/06/1950 Tarashcha | Tarashcha Court, 31/08/2010 |
| 240. | 28170/12 25/04/2012 | Oleksandr Petrovych TRETYAK 23/04/1960 Svitlovodsk | Svitlovodsk Court, 30/07/2009, as amended by the same court on 30/11/2009 |
| 241. | 11635/13 07/07/2009 | Nadiya Volodymyrivna PARKHOMENKO 10/05/1954 Nova Kakhovka | Nova Kakhovka Court, 23/04/2008 |
APPENDIX 2
(inadmissible applications)
| APPENDIX 2 (inadmissible applications) | |||
| No. | Application no. and date of introduction | Applicant name date of birth place of residence | Relevant domestic decision |
| 242. | 25461/10 19/03/2010 | Oleksandr Ivanovych BEREZA 27/08/1956 Vinnytsya | Zamostyanskyy District Court of Vinnytsya, 25/09/2009 |
| 243. | 32650/11 03/05/2011 | Petro Grygorovych KONVISAROV 09/05/1947 Vinnytsya | Vinnytsya Circuit Administrative Court, 14/12/2009 |
| 244. | 38898/11 15/06/2011 | Yuriy Mykolayovych KYSELYOV 27/11/1962 Starokostyantyniv | Zamostyanskyy District Court of Vinnytsya, 11/12/2006 |
| 245. | 42826/11 04/07/2011 | Ganna Pavlivna IVAKHNO 28/02/1941 Yagotyn | Yagotyn Court, 04/02/2010 |
| 246. | 43547/11 07/07/2011 | Bogdan Mykhaylovych YAROTSKYY 27/02/1956 Ostriv | Sokal Court, 03/09/2009, as amended by the Lviv Regional Court of Appeal on 16/02/2010 |
| 247. | 45331/11 09/07/2011 | Tetyana Volodymyrivna LYSENKO 11/12/1981 Sosnivka | Chervonograd Court, 10/08/2009 |
| 248. | 66805/11 24/10/2011 | Valeriy Ivanovych SOYMIN 14/04/1953 Kharkiv | Leninskyy District Court of Lugansk, 5/01/2005 |
| 249. | 71028/11 10/11/2011 | Alena Ivanovna TOKARYUK 05/02/1985 Odesa | Odesa Circuit Administrative Court, 10/07/2009, as amended by the Odesa Administrative Court of Appeal on 28/04/2010 |
| 250. | 75042/11 26/11/2011 | Vladimir Yevdokimovich GAPON 19/03/1936 Zaporizhzhya | Ordzhonikidzevskyy District Court of Zaporizhzhya, 30/12/2010 |
