BAILII is celebrating 24 years of free online access to the law! Would you
consider making a contribution?
No donation is too small. If every visitor before 31 December gives just £1, it
will have a significant impact on BAILII's ability to continue providing free
access to the law.
Thank you very much for your support!
You are here:BAILII >>
Databases >>
Scottish Court of Session Decisions >>
Robert Sym, Trustee for Jackson's Creditors, v Alexander Simson. [1757] Mor 1212 (16 November 1757)
URL: http://www.bailii.org/scot/cases/ScotCS/1757/Mor0301212-248.html Cite as:
[1757] Mor 1212
Disposition by a Bankrupt in favour of his whole Creditors.
Robert Sym, Trustee for Jackson's Creditors, v. Alexander Simson
Date: 16 November 1757 Case No. No 248.
Creditors having carried away by diligence great part of a bankrupt's effects; at a meeting of them all but one, he executed a disposition of the remainder to a trustee for their behoof, according to their diligence. The single creditor took separate measures; found ineffectual.
Click here to view a pdf copy of this documet : PDF Copy
Patrick and James Jacksons having become bankrupt, and their creditors having, upon different diligences, carried off the greatest part of their effects, the Jacksons, at a general meeting of almost all their creditors, except Alexander Simson, executed a disposition of the remainder of their effects to Robert Sym, as trustee for all their creditors. The disposition was simple, and unqualified; reserved the several rights and preferences of the creditors; enumerated them all; referred to a signed inventory of the debtor's effects; and contained none but the most common and ordinary clauses necessary for its receiving execution.
In consequence of this disposition, the creditors stopped their diligences.
Two months after, Alexander Simson, who had not used any diligence before, arrested in the hands of Robert Sym, for a debt due to him by the Jacksons. The Sheriff decerned in the furthcoming; Robert Sym advocated the cause.
Simson pleaded, in the advocation, That a disposition omninum bonorum by a bankrupt, could not stop the diligence of creditors.
Sym made answer upon the common argument made use of in support of such dispositions. And, 2do, That the case in hand was more favourable than the common case of such general dispositions; for that it was only a conveyance of the remaining part of the bankrupt's estate, after the greatest part of it had been torn away by diligence; and that, even of it, the division had, before the meeting of the creditors, been already fixed by the diligences which the creditors had by that time used, in which those only who had diligences had an interest, and in which Simson had no interest, it not being denied, that if the other creditors had gone on in their diligences, without using the trust-disposition, there would not have been left any thing for him to have drawn.
‘The Lords assoilzied Robert Sym.’
For Sym, J. Dalrymple, Geo. Brown.For Simson, Arch. Murray, Lockhart.
Fol. Dic. v. 3. p. 64. Fac. Col. No 59. p. 97.
